Multiple Choice – Section 03: Why Economists Disagree 1.“Ifalleconomistswerelaidendtoend,theywouldnotreachaconclusion.”Whomadethiswhimsicalobservation? a.HarryTruman b.GeorgeBernardShaw c.JohnMaynardKeynes d.RonaldReagan 2.PresidentRonaldReaganoncejokedthataTrivialPursuitgamedesignedforeconomistswould a.havenoquestionsbuthundredsofanswers. b.have100questionsand3,000answers. c.have1,000questionsbutnoanswers. d.neverproduceawinner. 3.Economistssometimesgiveconflictingadvicebecause a.graduatestudentsineconomicsareencouragedtoarguewitheachother. b.economistshavedifferentvaluesandscientificjudgment. c.economistsactingasscientistsdonotliketoagreewitheconomistsactingaspolicyadvisers. d.economicsismoreofabeliefsystemthanascience. 4.Thetwobasicreasonswhyeconomistsoftenappeartogiveconflictingadvicetopolicymakersaredifferencesin a.opinionsandeducation. b.opinionsandvalues. c.scientificjudgmentsandeducation. d.scientificjudgmentsandvalues. 5.Sometimeseconomistsdisagreebecausetheirscientificjudgmentsdiffer.Whichofthefollowinginstancesbestreflectsthissourceofdisagreement? a.Oneeconomistbelieveseveryoneshouldpaythesamepercentageoftheirincomeintaxes;anothereconomistbelievesthatwealthiercitizensshouldpayahigherpercentageoftheirincomeintaxes. b.Oneeconomistbelievesthatmanufacturingfirmsshouldfacegreaterregulationtopreservetheenvironment;anothereconomistbelievesthegovernmentshouldnotinterveneinfreemarkets. c.Oneeconomistbelievesthatequalityshouldbevaluedoverefficiencyinpolicydecisions;anothereconomistbelievesthatefficiencyshouldbevaluedoverequalityinpolicydecisions. d.Oneeconomistbelievesthegovernmentshouldtaxahousehold’sincome?anothereconomistbelievesthegovernmentshouldtaxahousehold’sconsumption. 6.Differencesinscientificjudgementbetweeneconomistsaresimilartoallofthefollowingexcept a.astronomersdebatingwhetherthesunorearthwasatthecenterofthesolarsystem. b.meteorologistsdebatingtheexistenceofglobalwarming. c.twopoliticiansarguingaboutthefairnessofthetaxcode. d.explorersdebatingwhetherornottheearthwasflatbeforethetimeofChristopherColumbus. 7.Sometimeseconomistsdisagreebecausetheirvaluesdiffer.Whichofthefollowinginstancesbestreflectsthissourceofdisagreement? a.OneeconomistbelievestheNorthAmericanFreeTradeAgreement(NAFTA)hasledtoalossofAmericanjobs;anothereconomistdisputesthisclaim. b.Oneeconomistbelievesthatwhenincometaxesarecut,peoplewillincreasetheirspending;anothereconomistbelievesthatwhenincometaxesarecut,peoplewillincreasetheirsaving. c.Oneeconomistadvisesagainstincreasesinsalestaxesbecauseshethinkssuchincreasesareunfairtolow-incomepeople;anothereconomistdisputestheideathatincreasesinsalestaxesareunfairtolow-incomepeople. d.Oneeconomistbelievesthat,priortotheCivilWar,slaverycontributedtoeconomicgrowthintheSouth;anothereconomistbelievesthatslaveryheldbacktheSouth’seconomicgrowth. 8.JoeandFredareeconomists.Joethinksthatthewealthiest10%oftheUSpopulationshouldbetaxedaratehigherthantherestofsocietybecausetheycanbetteraffordit.Fredthinksthateveryoneshouldbetaxedatthesameratebecausethatisthefairestscenarioandthewealthyshouldnotbepenalizedfortheirsuccess.Inthisexample,JoeandFred a.disagreeaboutthevalidityofapositivetheory. b.havedifferentnormativeviewsabouttaxpolicy. c.mustbothbeincorrectbecausetaxpolicyisneverthatsimple. d.Noneoftheaboveiscorrect. 9.Whichofthefollowingisoneofthebasicreasonswhyeconomistsoftenappeartogiveconflictingadvicetopolicymakers? a.similaropinionsaboutthevalidityofeconomictheories b.significantdifferencesineducation c.differencesinpersonalvalues d.arelianceonnormativestatementforresearchtheories 10.YiandAvikarebotheconomists.Yithinksthattaxingconsumption,ratherthanincome,wouldresultinhigherhouseholdsavingbecauseincomethatissavedwouldnotbetaxed.Avikdoesnotthinkthathouseholdsavingwouldrespondmuchtoachangeinthetaxlaws.In thisexample, Yiand Avik a.holddifferentnormativeviewsaboutthetaxsystem. b.disagreeaboutthevalidityofapositivetheory. c.haveafundamentalmisunderstandingofthetaxsystem. d.Morethanoneoftheaboveiscorrect.